Alleged Illegal Activities of Planned Parenthood (AKA MURDERHOOD)

Listen to this commercial:


“A recent radio ad from Keller’s Riverside Store located on the beautiful Llano River in the heart of Texas. I love truth in advertising and this ad ranks right up there with this Mobile Home Commercial from Robert Lee of Cullman Liquidation in Alabama.

http://biggeekdad.com/2011/10/kellers-riverside-store/

—

I plan to discuss the election tomorrow. I need some time to research the results and for the results to be solidified. I received the following this morning. Didn’t know about brothers day. They have a day or month for everything these days!

—

From: http://www.lifenews.com/2012/10/26/whistleblower-cases-show-planned-parenthood-engages-in-massive-fraud/

“Whistleblower Cases Show Planned Parenthood Engages in Massive Fraud

by Americans United for Life Legal Team
Washington, DC
LifeNews.com
10/26/12 6:23 PM

Planned Parenthood insists it is a necessary and trusted healthcare provider that must be supported by taxpayer dollars. Recently unsealed ‘whistleblower’ lawsuits[i] tell a starkly different story. Former Planned Parenthood employees allege improper and illegal corporate policies were implemented by Planned Parenthood to increase profits, to the detriment of both the taxpayers and the women and families government programs seek to serve.

In the most recently unsealed suit, Thayer v. Planned Parenthood of the Heartland,[ii] Sue Thayer, former manager for Planned Parenthood of the Heartland (PPH), alleges that PPH filed nearly one-half million false claims with Medicaid. According to Ms. Thayer’s complaint, PPH fraudulently received and retained nearly $28 million in taxpayer funding through abusive billing practices.

Ms. Thayer alleges that to enhance revenues, PPH implemented a ‘C-Mail’ program that effectively mailed thousands of unrequested birth control pills to women, and then billed the government for these pills. According to her complaint, PPH also solicited funds from patients for services fully covered by government programs while continuing to bill the government program for full reimbursement.

PPH’s C-Mail program eliminated the standard three month follow-up examination and instead mailed a one-year supply of birth control pills to clients who had only been seen once at a Planned Parenthood clinic.

According to Ms. Thayer, the C-Mail program was particularly designed for Medicaid-eligible patients ‘due to its revenue potential to Planned Parenthood’[iii] In mid-2006, PPH sought to maximize its profit-enhancing scheme. The affiliate:

‘[C]onverted the original ‘opt-in’ C-Mail program to a mandatory C-Mail program whereby, usually without the advance knowledge and/or written consent of the patient and/or without informing the patient that the patient could affirmatively decline to participate in Planned Parenthood’s C-Mail program, each patient was, at the time of the initial examination, prescribed [birth control] for one full year or 13 menstrual cycles.’[iv]

In some cases, patients had moved so the Postal Service returned the birth control pills to PPH. Instead of crediting the government or making an adjustment to its billing or reimbursements, Ms. Thayer states in her complaint that PPH ‘instructed its staff’ to re-use these pills and send them to future patients, effectively billing government healthcare programs at least twice for the same birth control pills.[v]

Even when patients contacted PPH and requested that they cease sending the birth control pills, Ms. Thayer states that PPH persisted in its fraudulent billing habits.[vi]

This scheme had great financial benefit to PPH. Ms. Thayer states that PPH’s cost for a 28-day supply of birth control pills (one menstrual cycle) was $2.98, yet PPH was reimbursed $26.32 from Medicaid for each one menstrual cycle supply provided to a patient.[vii]

In addition, Ms. Thayer alleges that PPH’s C-Mail program ‘created a medically unnecessary surplus of at least 120.96 doses (approximately a four-month supply) … for each client each year.’[viii]

Ms. Thayer’s complaint estimates that the program resulted in over $14 million in taxpayer funds that were misappropriated by PPH. [ix]

PPH is not the only Planned Parenthood affiliate facing serious charges of misconduct.

Two additional ‘whistleblower’ lawsuits have been filed against Planned Parenthood Gulf Coast (PPGC), Planned Parenthood’s fourth largest affiliate that operates 10 clinics in Texas and 2 clinics in Louisiana.

Karen Reynolds, a ‘Health Center Assistant’ for nearly 10 years at a Planned Parenthood clinic in Lufkin, Texas, alleges in her complaint that, in several government-funded programs, PPGC employees were trained to and did bill the government for medical services never actually provided, as well as for services that were not medically necessary.[x]

For example, Ms. Reynolds alleges that she and other PPGC employees:

‘[W]ere instructed, through policies handed down by PPGC corporate officers… and reiterated and enforced by local clinic directors … that if they had a patient using a single method of birth control … they should simply hand her a brown paper bag containing condoms and vaginal film as she walked out the door.’[xi]

After handing the patient this bag, PPGC would then charge the government for ‘counseling’ the patient and claim reimbursement for products never requested by the patient.

As Ms. Reynolds describes, ‘[T]he decision about what services to provide patients was driven by what services the various government programs would pay for, as opposed to the medical necessity of the various procedures and tests.’[xii]

A second ‘whistleblower’ lawsuit against PPGC, Johnson v. Planned Parenthood Gulf Coast, [xiii] corroborates Ms. Reynolds’ claims.

Abby Johnson worked at PPGC’s clinic in Bryan, Texas from September 2001 until she resigned in October 2009. Ms. Johnson alleges that, from the beginning of the Texas WHP program in January 2007, members of Planned Parenthood’s Key Management Team[xiv] instructed the managers of each of PPGC’s 10 Texas clinics to bill for products and services ineligible for reimbursement under the Texas Women’s Health Program.[xv]

According to Ms. Johnson’s allegations, through its billing scheme PPGC improperly received over $5 million in taxpayer funding.

Earlier this year, the Texas Health and Human Services Commission issued a rule that precludes abortion providers from participation in the Texas Women’s Health Program.[xvi] Planned Parenthood, an abortion provider impacted by the rule, immediately challenged the Texas law,[xvii] exemplifying a brazen attitude pervasive throughout the organization: Planned Parenthood believes that it is entitled to receive taxpayer dollars.

Planned Parenthood’s demand for continued taxpayer largesse in Texas is perhaps ironic considering the ‘whistleblower’ lawsuits it faces. The allegations brought by Ms. Reynolds and Ms. Johnson, if proved true, mean PPGC has been depriving Texan women of millions of dollars in services and care they could have otherwise received.

Importantly, neither lawsuit against PPGC claims that the misconduct was by ‘rogue’ employees or that the alleged instances of improper billing were isolated incidents or the result of mere oversight. In both cases, Ms. Reynolds and Ms. Johnson state that the improper billing practices stemmed from Planned Parenthood’s corporate policies and were part of an affiliate-wide management scheme to raise PPGC’s revenue.

The taxpayers are not the only targets of Planned Parenthood’s profit-enhancing schemes. According to Ms. Thayer’s complaint, PPH’s increased its profits by exploiting the poor women it ‘served.’

Ms. Thayer states in her complaint that PPH trained its employees to (and did) solicit money from Medicaid clients at the time services were rendered. Employees recommended to patients that they give ‘50 percent of the amount of the bill’ to PPH. [xviii] In soliciting these ‘suggested donations,’ as PPH called them, PPH failed to inform patients that the entire amount of the bill would be reimbursed by the government.[xix]

After receiving ‘hundreds of thousands of dollars’ from these patients, PPH would then bill Medicaid for the same services in full, which violates its legal duty to submit accurate claims to the government for payment.[xx] Ms. Thayer alleges that PPH used the money it collected from the pockets of its Medicaid patients ‘for purposes unrelated to the provisions of Title XIX-Medicaid services to such patients.’[xxi]

In effect, PPH both falsely billed government programs and took money from low-income women by convincing them to pay for services already covered in full.

The allegations in the Reynolds, Johnson, and Thayer ‘whistleblower’ lawsuits that Planned Parenthood trains its employees to disregard the law and to engage in fraudulent billing practice suggests that Planned Parenthood places its financial bottom line above all else.

These cases buttress the growing body of evidence that Planned Parenthood is a bad investment for the American taxpayer. As Americans United for Life’s 2011 report The Case for Investigating Planned Parenthood documented, state audit reports and admissions by former Planned Parenthood employees detail a pattern of misuse of federal healthcare and family planning funds by some Planned Parenthood affiliates.[xxii] Planned Parenthood affiliates in California, New Jersey, New York, and Washington State, for example, have been exposed for abusing taxpayer dollars.[xxiii]

If the allegations in these ‘whistleblower’ cases prove true in a court of law, the American public should be gravely concerned. Billing government programs for services never provided, that are medically unnecessary, or that patients already pay for in part depletes limited government healthcare dollars and deprives women of funding for actual healthcare services.

LifeNews Note: Americans United for Life (AUL) is a nonprofit, public-interest law and policy organization whose vision is a nation in which everyone is welcomed in life and protected in law.

Footnotes are available on the website:

http://www.lifenews.com/2012/10/26/whistleblower-cases-show-planned-parenthood-engages-in-massive-fraud/

—

Just for fun:

“THESE REALLY WORK!! I checked this out on Snopes and they’re for real! ...

AMAZING, SIMPLE HOME REMEDIES:

1) AVOID CUTTING YOURSELF WHEN SLICING VEGETABLES BY GETTING SOMEONE ELSE TO HOLD THE VEGETABLES WHILE YOU CHOP.

2) FOR HIGH BLOOD PRESSURE SUFFERERS ~ SIMPLY CUT YOURSELF AND BLEED FOR A FEW MINUTES, THUS REDUCING THE PRESSURE ON YOUR VEINS. REMEMBER TO USE A TIMER AND THEN A BANDAID.

3) A MOUSE TRAP PLACED ON TOP OF YOUR ALARM CLOCK WILL PREVENT YOU FROM ROLLING OVER AND GOING BACK TO SLEEP AFTER YOU HIT THE SNOOZE BUTTON.

4) YOU NEED ONLY TWO TOOLS IN LIFE—WD-40 AND DUCT TAPE. IF IT DOESN’T
MOVE AND SHOULD, USE THE WD-40. IF IT SHOULDN’T MOVE AND DOES, USE THE DUCT TAPE.

5) IF YOU CAN’T FIX IT WITH A HAMMER, YOU’VE GOT AN ELECTRICAL PROBLEM.

THOUGHT for the day:

SOME PEOPLE ARE LIKE SLINKIES—NOT REALLY GOOD FOR ANYTHING BUT THEY BRING A SMILE TO YOUR FACE WHEN THEY’RE PUSHED DOWN THE STAIRS.”

OK, I don’t recommend the thought for the day!